Monday, February 11, 2013

Graber Censorship


When it comes to the three solutions which Graber describes when it comes to the censorship of the news, I believe that the ‘formal censorship’ approach is the most appropriate during the time of a crisis. I believe that there are times where legislation should set forth things that can and can not be published for the safety of American citizens. Despite the fact that freedom of the press is such an important aspect to our country, I have no problem reeling it back if there will be harmful consequences to publishing information that contains detrimental information.

Leaving journalists free to decide in a completely ‘free press’ situation could have major consequences. If reporters continue to write at their own discretion they could say things that hurt the morale of citizens. When trying to keep everyone calm during a crisis situation it is not a great idea to have reporters talking about how terrible it actually is. Also, if there is any information that reporters did not know could be useful to terrorists the government given their knowledge should be able to intervene and tell them that it is not appropriate to have those things in the news. As an American citizen who believes in the ideals backing the freedom of the press, I believe that national security concerns are the most important things and should have a much higher priority than press freedom during the times of crisis.

Despite this fact, the issues that this system showed during the Vietnam War are rather alarming. The sketchiness that accompanied Vietnam were endless and definitely further than any civilian could even imagine. It is scary to think that while that was happening over seas, the government could be lying about this that are happening in order to gain support for their actions. I believe that the government should have the right to censor on the basis of national security. However I am very skeptical of allowing them to lie to people in order to rally support for something that really isn’t happening. That is the only down side to government censorship and I hope that it does not happen to frequently.